Article text from the Seattle Times online newspaper, the full story can be found at:http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/eastsidenews/2002278945_donkey18e.htmlWednesday, May 18, 2005 - Page updated at 12:00 a.m.
Skyline school benches donkey basketball
By Cara Solomon
Seattle Times Eastside bureau
The fund-raiser at Skyline High School in Sammamish would have featured a game of hoops with players seated astride actual donkeys. Proceeds from "donkey basketball," which had been scheduled for yesterday, would have helped pay for the school's student-body activities.
But concerns over animal cruelty have stopped it in its tracks.
According to the district, a Skyline student brought his concerns to the school's Associated Student Body (ASB) last week, and the student council decided Thursday morning to cancel the event.
A few students at the school of more than a thousand complained about this. A few. Let's take that as ten, which I think is more than the real number, but it is nice and round. So, ten people complain that they think this is cruel to the donkeys.
On the radio I listened to a member of PETA and the local host talk about this. The lady from PETA said it was cruel in part because the animal does not know what he is doing out there. He is confused by everything. He is being laughed at by everyone.
I have a few issues with all this. First off when did the country decide that the majority no longer rules? I never got the memo. I never was told that when one person doesn't like something, we will cancel it because we don't want to force things that are offensive on someone who would be offended.
On a tangent now... one must choose to be offended. I need to post about that one of these days and explain myself. But those who are offended choose to be.
I am back... This was not cancelled because of someone being offended, but because of a concern over cruelty to the animals. Why would they schedule this and then cancel? If it was cruel, it would have been cruel before they scheduled it, not after someone brings it up. So a "few" people see this as cruel, therefore it is now deemed as such. Is that how hanging became "cruel"?
Anyway, the point I am trying to make is that we have become a nation of overcompensating rulers trying to protect the minority at the expense of the majority.
Next, there is PETA claiming that the donkeys are confused. When I moved to a new house I could say my dog was confused at first. She did not recognize her surroundings, but soon she learned her new surroundings and life was good.
So, you have these donkeys that are raised to play basketball. How can you say they are confused? That is what they have been doing their whole life. Sure, take a donkey from the Grand Canyon and put it on a basketball court, and it would be confused. There is a concern about the basketball hitting the donkeys. It is not like dodgeball where the basketballs are thrown at the donkeys at a high rate of speed. I am sure the donkey doesn't like it when the ball bounces off of him, but is that really "cruel"?
As for being laughed at, I bet the ones being laughed at are the people riding the donkeys, not the donkeys themselves. She did say that we should not in today's world use animals are workers. Police dogs - cruel. Service dogs - that is a grey issue. Horses pulling stuff - no need for it in a mechanical world. She made it clear that no matter what an animal is used for it is cruel unless the animal is allowed to roam free around the world. However, cutting off their sex organs is okay. I did learn that from her. We can choose to make the animal celibate for life, but that is all the power we have over animals.
The bottom line is that this is not cruel. PETA and those complaining don't know what it means to be cruel to animals. Look at what some kids in Seattle did in 1994. They beat a donkey to death. It was a donkey tied to a tree. There was an article I just read about some teenagers burning chickens alive and others were using lacrosse sticks to bat around some other chickens.
That is cruel. Playing basketball is not.